charity over torah

 על כן אהוביי אחיי

Therefore, my beloved ones, my brethren:

שימו נא לבבכם לאלה הדברים הנאמרים בקצרה מאד

Direct your hearts to these words which are expressed very briefly,

ואם ירצה ה׳, פנים אל פנים אדבר בם בארוכה

(1and face to face, please G‑d, I will speak of them at length) —

איך היות כל עיקר עבודת ה׳ בעתים הללו, בעקבות משיחא, היא עבודת הצדקה

how in these times, when the approaching footsteps of Mashiach are close upon us, the principal service of G‑d is the service of charity.

כמו שאמרו רז״ל: אין ישראל נגאלין אלא בצדקה

As our Sages, of blessed memory, said:2 “Israel will be redeemed only through charity.”

ולא אמרו רז״ל: תלמוד תורה שקול כנגד גמילות חסדים

Our Sages, of blessed memory, did not say that the study of Torah is equivalent to the performance of acts of lovingkindness,

The Mishnah states in Peah:3 “The study of Torah is equivalent to them all,” i.e., to all the mitzvot previously enumerated in the Mishnah, and these include gemilut chassadim, the performance of acts of lovingkindness,

אלא בימיהם

except in their own days.

שתלמוד תורה היה עיקר העבודה אצלם, ועל כן היו חכמים גדולים, תנאים ואמוראים

For with them the principal area of divine service was the study of the Torah, which is why at that time there were great scholars: tannaim and amoraim.

מה שאין כן בעקבות משיחא

However, in a time when the approaching footsteps of Mashiach are close upon us,

שנפלה סוכת דוד עד בחינת רגלים ועקביים, שהיא בחינת עשיה

as “the Sukkah of David has fallen” to a level of “feet” and “heels”, i.e., to the level of Asiyah,

I.e., the Sefirah called Malchut of Atzilut, the Shechinah that vests itself in the lower Worlds of BeriahYetzirah and Asiyah — also known as the “Sukkah of David,” for David, as the King of Israel, was a merkavah to Malchut of Atzilut — has fallen to the lowest level of Asiyah.

אין דרך לדבקה בה באמת

there is no way of truly cleaving unto it, i.e., to the Shechinah,

ולהפכא חשוכא לנהורא דילה

and transforming the darkness of the world into its light,4

כי אם בבחינת עשיה גם כן

except through a corresponding category of action, and not through intellect and speech alone, as in Torah study,

שהיא מעשה הצדקה

namely, the act of charity.

But why is charity unique among all the many commandments that involve action?

כידוע למשכילים, שבחינת עשיה באלקות היא בחינת השפעת והמשכת החיות למטה מטה, למאן דלית ליה מגרמיה כלום

As is known to the scholarly, “action” with reference to Divinity is the diffusion and downward flow of vitality to the lowest depths — to him who has nothing of his own.

Among the currents of Divine influence that descend into the various worlds, there are those that are called “thought” and “speech”. The flow of vitality to the very lowest level — to the World of Asiyah, where G‑dliness is not at all manifest — is called “action”.

The act of giving tzedakah thus truly corresponds to the spiritual level of Asiyah, inasmuch as it too provides beneficence to one “who has nothing of his own.”

וכל הזובח את יצרו בזה

And whoever sacrifices his impulse in this respect, i.e., with respect to charity,

ופותח ידו ולבבו

and opens his hand and heart,

אתכפיא סטרא אחרא

[thereby] causes5 “the other [i.e., evil] side” of the universe to be subjugated,

ומהפך חשוכא לאור ה׳ יתברך, השוכן עלינו בבחינת עשיה בעקבות משיחא

and6 “converts the darkness into the light” of G‑d, blessed be He, Who, in the time when the footsteps of Mashiach are close upon us, dwells over us in a state of action;

ויזכה לראות עין בעין, בשוב ה׳ ציון כו׳

moreover, he will merit to7 “behold Eye to eye, G‑d returning to Zion....”

At that time the physical eye, though yet retaining its physicality, will behold G‑dliness as it is beheld by the Supernal Eye. Thus, within the physicality of the World of Asiyah, there will be revealed the level of certainty in spiritual perception which is called vision — a level that far surpasses the furthest attainments of the intellect.

FOOTNOTES
1.Parentheses are in the original text.
2.

Note of the Rebbe: “See RambamHilchot Matnot Aniyim, beginning of ch. 10; quoted in Tur, Yoreh Deah, beginning of sec. 247. The above quotation does not refer to the similar teaching in the Talmud (Shabbat 139a; Sanhedrin 98a), for there the verb is נפדה [whereas our text reads נגאלין]. Very often, as is well known, the commentators {(the Radbaz and the Kesef Mishneh and the Glosses on the Tur) who give the teaching of Ulla in the Talmud (loc. cit.) as Rambam’s source} do not intend to quote the exact wording of a particular teaching, but rather to cite its content. See also the halachah that immediately follows this statement in the Rambam, and the above-named commentaries on it.“

As to Mesoret HaShas and the other authorities who argue that the Rambam had before him the text ‘Israel’ (in place of ‘Jerusalem’) in the Talmud, they speak only of the one word ‘Israel’, and such a variant reading is to be found elsewhere — in Ein Yaakov. A version that would include nigalin, however, I have yet to find in the Talmud or in Yalkut Shimoni.

Moreover, it is more improbable to postulate that the Rambam had a variant reading that is not at all extant, than to assume that the Rambam is more explicit than the Talmud, for which reason he very understandably writes nigalin.”

3.1:1.
4.V.L.: לנהורא דיליה (“to his light”).
5.Cf. Likkutei Amarim, Part I, ch. 27.
6.Cf. Likkutei Amarim, Part I, ch. 27.
7.Yeshayahu 52:8.

Harav Chaim Yakov Vidrevitz

 

THE FIRST LUBAVITCHER ROV IN AMERICA

Harav Chaim Yakov Vidrevitz, chossid of the Tzemach Tzedek and Rebbe Maharash, arrived in the US in 5652/1892 and did much to improve Yiddishkeit in America. Marking his 110th yahrtzeit.

By Hershel Rosenbluh for Anash.org

Harav Chaim Yakov Vidrevitz, a chossid of the Tzemach Tzedek and Rebbe Maharash, who was the Moscow rov and later came to America to serve as rov in New York, passed away on 12 Iyar, 5671/1911.

Harav Vidrevitz in his early years

Harav Vidrevitz was born in Dobromisla, in the Mohilev gubernya (province), to his father Reb Binyomin, on 8 Kislev 5596. A young prodigy, he soon mastered all of shas and poskim and at a very young age. Although from a non-chassidishe background, upon the advice of a friend he traveled to Lubavitch to be one of the yoshvim by the Tzemach Tzedek (these were studious young men who came for extended periods of time to sit and learn and have all their expenses covered by the Rebbe).

After marrying his wife Tamara, he was accepted as a rov in several White Russian towns. In 5636/1876, he then was sent by the Rebbe Maharash to become the Chassidishe rov in Moscow, where he served for 15 years, earning him the title, the “Moskver Rov.”

In Moscow, his fame as a great gaon and posek spread far and wide, throughout the Russian Empire and beyond. He was tasked by the children of the Tzemach Tzedek to organize the ksovim and to print the tshuvos of the Tzemach Tzedek. The responsa that we have is due to his hard work over a two-year period. He was greatly opposed to the maskilim who tried to make changes to the old Jewish way of life. As rov in Moscow he was called by the Rebbe Rashab to oversee the renovation of the mikveh in Lubavitch that fell into disrepair, after the Rebbe Maharash’s histalkus.

Jewish market in Moscow

In 5651/1891, after upheavals in Russia and an attempt on the Czar’s life, a large portion of the Jews of Moscow was expelled, and Rav Vidrevitz decided to head towards the American shores. There he was appointed as rov of the Lubavitcher-Nyezhiner shul on Henry Street on the East Side of New York. Four years later, he was joined by the esteemed chossid Reb Avrohom Chaim Rosenbaum – who came to New York after writing to R. Chaim Yaakov and receiving a response that he will help him settle upon arrival.

In New York, his star began to shine even more and he accomplished much in the realm of strengthening Yiddishkeit in the “treifene medineh,” specifically in the areas of kashrus and mikvaos. He worked independently, as well as together with the “Rav Hakolel,” Harav Yakov Yosef, to bring order to a wilderness. His wit and genius were well-known throughout the land. Despite his speech impediment, people would come from near and far to hear his drashos and to have him mediate their disputes.

Due to his genius and wit, he became a well-known figure in the American-Yiddish press. A story was told that he once had a dispute with a business partner, where Rav Vidrevitz accused the partner of taking what wasn’t his. The partner, in his audacity, proceeded to accuse the Rov of stealing! The rov responded to his partner: “I’m a liar and you have a stuttering problem!” The partner was bewildered and responded: “You have a stuttering problem!” To which the rov replied: “Yes, but if you accuse me with your shortcomings, then I’ll accuse you with mine!”

While in the US, Rav Vidrevitz went by different titles at different times, including “Chief Rabbi of America” which was painted on a sign outside his home. When questioned who appointed him to be the Chief Rabbi, he answered in jest “The sign painter!”

Harav Vidrevitz in the US

After the passing of Rav Yakov Yosef – known as the Rav Hakolel – in 5662/1902, most rabbonim joined together and formed the Agudas HoRabbonim. For reasons unbeknownst to us, Rav Vidrevitz did not join them and even was at odds with them. When the Agudas HoRabbonim announced that only their kashrus and shechitah should be trusted, Rav Vidrevitch responded that people need not pay heed to that. He said he knows many frumerliche rabbonim that didn’t join the Agudas HoRabbonim and their hechsherim are even better than the Agudah’s. He added that while the Agudas HoRabbonim’s announcement was well intended, it was a chillul Hashem to discredit all the other rabbonim.

His disagreement with the Agudas HoRabbonim might have been the cause for some people to suspect him of disrespecting the Rav Hakolel and that he was lax in Halacha. There was also another reason for opposition.

Rav Joseph was a talmid of Reb Yisroel Salanter and what you might call the leader of the Litvishe/misnagdishe yidden in New York. The misnagdishe yidden in New York put forth the idea that Rav Vidrevitz, the rov of the chassidim, was lacking in respect to Rav Yosef and to Yiddishkeit in general. They painted all the chassidim with a broad brush and claimed that all chassidim are at fault that, in the later years, Rav Yoseph’s rabbonus was fraught with problems. In truth, Rav Yoseph’s opponents were two prominent Litvishe rabbonim while Rav Vidrevitch stood by his side.

It’s worthwhile noting that after the passing of Rav Yakov Yoseph, Rav Vidrevitch was part of a committee that was actively trying to recruit Rav Yakov Dovid Wilowski of Slutsk – the Ridvaz – to be the replacement for Rav Yoseph.

Rav Vidrevitz also was very strongly opposed to a controversial rov who arrived in the US and settled in Hoboken, NJ – Rabbi Chaim Hirshenson. Rabbi Hirshenson saw the sorry situation of Yiddishkeit, and with good intentions, he prepared a sefer called “Halichos Olam,” to introduce the masses to leniencies in halacha. Rav Vidrevitz wrote many articles against him and his writings, that were published in a journal named “Hamitzpah.”

On the 12th of Iyar 5671/1911, after languishing in bed for eight days, he passed away. Thousands gathered for his levaya. The police, who knew from previous occasions of the large crowds that gather for the levaya of a prominent rov, made sure to keep tight control over the crowds. He was brought to kevurah to the Bayside Cemetery in Queens, right next to his son Yosef Tzvi, who predeceased him. A large matzeivoh was placed over both of their graves.

The Yiddish language Morgen-Journal had this to say about him after his passing: “He was one of the greatest geonim of his day. He fell ill eight days ago but remained in bed with seforim at his side – never ceasing to study Torah. He was great in Torah but also intelligent and well-versed in worldly matters Great industrialists and businessmen would come to him to seek his advice and to settle disputes they may have had.”

His own writings were never published, but his memory lives on in the writings of the Tzemach Tzedek that he compiled, as well as his scattered writings in various seforim and archives.

how is this any diff from what chassidim do?

ELUL

“What does Hashem your G-d require of you but to fear Hashem your G-d” (10:12)

The Gemoro (Brochos 33b) expresses surprise that the Torah designates the attainment of

fear of Heaven as a small matter, and replies that for Moshe it was indeed a small matter. The

meforshim ask the obvious question that this posuk is addressed to the whole nation and not only to

Moshe.

The Dubna Maggid explains in the name of the Vilna Gaon that someone who is privileged to

cleave to talmidei chachomim and spends much time in their presence will easily emulate their deeds 

and have no difficulty acquiring their fear of Heaven. A tzaddik suffuses his environment with his

yiras Shomayim like a vessel bursting at the seams. Moshe Rabbeinu, too, as the leader of the nation,

recognized the greatness of its members and realized that, due to their lofty levels, he was able to

convey his own superior level of yiras Shomayim to them. Thus, he told them that they did not have

to toil much, because they were close to him, and therefore in a position to attain the required level of

yiras Shomayim.


R Moshe Sternbuch